Under which circumstances should guardianship be considered?

Guardianship should be considered when an adult cannot manage their affairs due to impairment. This impairment could be due to various factors such as mental illness, cognitive decline, physical disabilities, or other circumstances that affect a person's ability to make informed decisions about their life and finances.

In these situations, a guardian can be appointed to make decisions in the best interest of the individual, ensuring that their personal and financial needs are met. It is crucial for the guardianship process to occur when a person's autonomy is compromised to prevent potential exploitation and to provide necessary support while respecting their dignity.

The other scenarios presented do not warrant the use of guardianship. For example, if an adult can manage their own affairs, guardianship would not be appropriate, as it would infringe upon their rights and independence. In cases where there is merely a disagreement within the family, it is essential to explore resolution methods that preserve family dynamics without resorting to legal guardianship. Lastly, while someone may wish to appoint assistance, this does not automatically escalate to guardianship, which is a legal process designed for those who genuinely lack the capacity to handle their own affairs.